1905 PARIS G&T MAURICE RENAUD French Baritone Gounod LE SOIR GC 3-32672
Then in November 1907 Mary Garden made her debut at the Manhattan in Massenet’s Thaïs, with Renaud as Athanaël. W. J. Henderson wrote that «His Athanaël has never been rivaled. Renaud’s greatest parts at the Manhattan included Don Giovanni, Scarpia, Germont, Hérode in Hérodiade, and the three villains in The Tales of Hoffmann.